Design Sketch Implementation Validation — Document Index (ARCHIVED)

Status: Superseded. See docs/developer/INDEX.md for the current, consolidated tracking of all design sketches, plans, status records, reviews, and validation packs.

This document is kept for historical reference. For current work status, consult:

Historical Contents (Below - for reference only)

Date completed: 2026-09-20 Task: Validate extent of implementation for 7 design sketches in /docs/developer/sketches/ Deliverables: Status docs (completed), plan docs (deferred work), summary cross-reference

Status Documents Created

Fully Implemented & Validated ✅

Sketch Status Document Summary
llm-training.md llm-training-mtp.md L0-L5 curriculum fully generated; 258 terms, 895 axioms; 9 lenses, 30+ cassettes; 20 output files; 346 tests passing
MTP-L0 Generator Sketch (included in llm-training-mtp.md) Facts extractor, doctrine pinning, axiom ownership gates all operational
MTP L2 Generator Sketch.md (included in llm-training-mtp.md) S1–S13 pipeline (corpus, partition, fidelity, mutate, render); mutation-derived ground truth working
mtp-implementation-plan.md mtp-execution.md Plan fully executed; every slice authored and validated; ready for Phase 7 backend integration

Implemented, Awaiting Runtime Validation ⏳

Sketch Status Document Summary
mork-eligibility-compiler.md eligibility-compiler.md Source complete (tools/mork_compilers/); three backends (SPARQL, SHACL, SWRL); 7 deliberate non-coverage areas documented; unit tests present, not yet executed

Partially Implemented (Skeleton UI) 🟡

Sketch Status Document Plan Document Summary
governance-and-versioning-migration.md governance-surfaces.md governance-surfaces-integration.md Studio and Bench fixture shells correct, role model demonstrated, permission enforcement not yet wired; 3 integration slices needed for Phase 2 & 5

Superseded/Archived 🗄️

Sketch Status Document Summary
implementation-handover.md implementation-handover-historical.md Phase 0–6 handover archived; refer to individual phase handoffs and platform-continuation status instead

Cross-Reference Document

Comprehensive validation summary: design-sketches-validation-summary.md

This single document provides:

Plan Documents Created

New Work Identified

Unit Plan Document Phase Scope
governance-surfaces-integration governance-surfaces-integration.md Phase 2 & 5 3 slices: Studio backend wiring, Bench permission model, evidence projection state

How to Use These Documents

To review implementation status:

  1. Start with design-sketches-validation-summary.md for the overview
  2. Find your sketch in the summary table
  3. Follow the link to the status document for that sketch
  4. Status documents cite evidence (code locations, test results, ADRs)

To find deferred work:

  1. Check design-sketches-validation-summary.md for “Partially Implemented”
  2. Open the linked plan document
  3. Plan documents describe slices, test strategy, and acceptance criteria

To understand MTP completion:

  1. Read llm-training-mtp.md — describes what’s built
  2. Read mtp-execution.md — describes plan execution (every slice done)
  3. Read mtp-implementation-plan.md — original plan document

To track governance surfaces work:

  1. Read governance-surfaces.md — what exists (fixture shells)
  2. Read governance-surfaces-integration.md — what’s needed (3 slices)

Key Results

Governing ADRs

All sketches are governed by their respective ADRs:

Next review: After Phase 7 LLM backend integration or Phase 2/5 governance surfaces implementation